What are some arguments against auteurist theory

What are some arguments against auteurist theory

Corman's ability to discover burgeoning talent, combined with his immense skill at analyzing the conventions of cinema, seem to suggest that he was no less an auteur than any other member of the cinematic elite. Unlike many other forms of art, Cinema is the direct result of the cooperative effort of hundreds of people, of which the director and cast are merely the most prominent. Selznick, David O. This led to critics engaging in long battles over the inclusion or exclusion of certain directors almost always male. Surely in a collaborative medium like cinema, actors, screenwriters, cinematographers, choreographers, composers, editors, designers, etc… occasionally have a great deal to do with the quality of the final product. New York: Decapo Press, And in the process, they set themselves up as the defenders of consumers against ostensibly shoddy, deceptive or somehow harmful merchandise. She wrote two of them, designed all of them. Read Richard Brody. But what many people fail to note is the fact that Hitchcock had very little success outside of the thriller genre, perhaps because he wasn't able to address his favorite recurring themes.

Alfred Hitchcock's films constantly addressed the plight of the wrongfully accused, as well as several other similarities, which are too numerous to cite. Perhaps this statement is yet another attempt to prove the supremacy of auteur theory, without first analyzing the magnitude in which a non-director can influence the outcome of a cinematic work.

With the emerging prominence of auteur based criticism in the ?

auteur theory pdf

Neither do I. Auteur theory is one particular theory of film authorship, which is an extremely broad subject. Surely in a collaborative medium like cinema, actors, screenwriters, cinematographers, choreographers, composers, editors, designers, etc… occasionally have a great deal to do with the quality of the final product.

Truffaut steers away from the avant-garde and moves towards a more general notion of the filmmaker as author in narrative cinema. In the case of many films produced during the golden age of "filmmaking", the studio was the auteur, and in some instances, this tradition carried over into the s and s.

He deserves credit for making four very good movies. We are fighting the notion that has evolved over the past fifty years which suggests that the film director is exclusively responsible for the quality of a movie.

problems with the auteur theory

As intriguing as this notion might seem, there is no doubt that auteur theory is an example of oversimplification at its finest. When asked why he chose these actors, Ford responded, "It's good to have actors you can trust, ones who will know their lines and be there"5 The recurrent theme throughout Ford's interviews about his filmmaking approach, seems to be the importance of a director surrounding himself with talented individuals.

Monty's improvements were saving the picture, and then two other writers walked off with Oscars for Best Screenplay.

When this film is analyzed and dissected, it is rarely the film's producer, Robert Evans who gets the credit. Selznick, David O.

Arguments against auteurism

Thanks for your support! This led to critics engaging in long battles over the inclusion or exclusion of certain directors almost always male. Sarris initially conceived of the Auteur Theory as a method for evaluating directors, and it has real value when used in that limited manner. A pretty significant impact on American film — and she never directed a thing. Reed, Rex. Today, most people will automatically answer director without giving it much thought. Andrew Sarris famously stated, "Feelings are expressed through actors, not by actors"6. Perhaps this statement is yet another attempt to prove the supremacy of auteur theory, without first analyzing the magnitude in which a non-director can influence the outcome of a cinematic work. There are simply too many talented artists involved in the creation of a movie to assign the director all the credit, all the time. Paul Thomas Anderson? Men such as Alfred Hitchcock, John Ford and Fritz Lange are believed to inhabit the ranks of the cinematic elite, and not surprisingly most critics are more than willing to bestow upon them the title of Auteur.
Rated 7/10 based on 61 review
Download
A Quick Guide To Auteur Theory